Hall of shameBest moments
Wrong guesses delivered with total confidence, the rare called shot, and the meltdowns in between. Every one jumps to the exact second.
🤡 Wrong guess
Am I Obama?
- You know, going into the office, 9:00 to 5:00, commute… white-collar, paper pusher.
- This is no cubicle.
- Okay. Am I Obama?
- No.
Guess the Character, round: characters with jobs.
💬 Quote
Method acting
- The prompt is… they want to end all life on Earth.
- How would you say it?
- I want to destroy you humans. I don't like you humans. You deserve to be annihilated, eradicated, obliterated.
💬 Quote
One sword, a hundred teenagers
- How many teenagers do you think I could fight off if I had a sword and they were unarmed? I could take a hundred.
- Listen, I'm not trying to defend myself, because 100 ain't even in the picture here.
🎯 Called it
The Ice Age detour
- Am I around, like, Ice Age creatures? Like saber-tooth tigers?
- Uh, no.
- Was I frozen?
- You weren't frozen.
- There's two versions of me?
- Yeah. In a sense.
- Am I SpongeBob?
- Yes, you're SpongeBob. You're caveman SpongeBob from the one episode where they went back in time.
🙈 The answer's hidden. Switch results on to see it.
🎯 Called itConnor
Connor might be cheating
- How are you cheating?
- I'm not. It's because I'm looking at what's on your head and it's helping me.
- It's helping me a little bit.
- Yes, you're Genji. What the ▇▇▇▇, dude? You guys are right. Connor might be cheating.
🙈 The answer's hidden. Switch results on to see it.
🎯 Called it
Voice actor roulette
- Am I Idris Elba?
- No.
- I love that guy.
- You have voiced a villain.
- Am I Jeremy Irons?
- God damn it. Yes, you're Jeremy Irons.
🙈 The answer's hidden. Switch results on to see it.
💥 Meltdown
It's got to be Serenity
- He's so ▇▇▇▇ sick. Open it up. Here it comes.
- It's got to be Serenity. Oh, what in the—
- No. NO. NO. NO.
- GOD DAMN IT!
🎯 Called it
Said it out loud, didn't lock it in
- Adult.
- Yep.
- Not for children.
- Like a Meatwad, maybe? But…
- …
- YES, YOU'RE MEATWAD.
The answer came up as a throwaway example 37 seconds before anyone actually guessed it.
🙈 The answer's hidden. Switch results on to see it.
🤡 Wrong guess
Seven names, seven no's
- Am I Gumball?
- No.
- Am I Frozone?
- No.
- Am I Megamind?
- No.
- Am I Mega Man?
- No.
- Am I Squidward?
- No.
- Am I Sonic?
- No.
- Whatever you're going to say is not going to be it.
- Am I Skeletor?
- No.
Seven guesses between 17:22 and 24:22. Not one of them was it.
💬 Quote
Tastes like Pan's Labyrinth
- Why does it taste like Trix cereal?
- Dude, I was going to say it tastes like berries.
- Is it the thing from Pan's Labyrinth?
- Yeah, that's what they taste like.
🤡 Wrong guess
Am I… my co-host?
- All right, this is the final round and both of you are tied…
- Am I sexy?
- I wouldn't say so.
- Am I Professor Lando?
- No.
- Dang it.
Tiebreaker, final round, everything on the line. The first move: check whether you're your co-host.
🤡 Wrong guess
Uncle Ben?
- You'd have to be a freak. Weird.
- That helps. Connor's very picky. Am I Uncle Ben?
- No.
- Fast food mascot. Jeez. Who am I missing?
🤡 Wrong guess
Cheese, stones, House
- Do I have superpowers?
- No.
- Um… cheese. Stones. House. Dr. House. Am I Dr. House?
- No. That's good. That's good.
Word association as a detective method.
💬 Quote
Ruled out: lube
- Like a household item?
- No.
- Great. You're not lube.
- Birds. Frogs, cows… am I Fox McCloud?
- No.
🤡 Wrong guess
The bald lightning round
- Do I have hair?
- You have no hair.
- Am I Daredevil?
- No. That's good, though.
- Am I Red Hood?
- No.
- Am I Hellboy?
- No.
- Am I Spider-Man?
- No.
- So ▇▇▇▇ stupid.
Got one we missed?
Send the episode and timestamp. The best ones end up on the wall.
Submit a moment